U.K., Nov. 19 -- UK Parliament issued the following news:

The Lord Speaker, Lord Forsyth of Drumlean, wrote to members on 19 November 2026 regarding the Restoration and Renewal programme for Parliament.

Read the letter here (pdf, 129KB)

My Lords,

The g overnment is expected to table a motion shortly on the future of the Restoration and Renewal (R&R) programme for the Palace of Westminster. This will be one of the most consequential decisions Parliament is likely to take, involving many billions of pounds of public expenditure, the preservation of our historic building and potentially profound changes to the way both Houses conduct their business.

I am writing to encourage all m embers to familiarise themselves with the issues before the motion is debated. Parliament must decide the future of Parliament, and it is essential that those decisions are taken with a full understanding of their financial, practical and constitutional consequences. This is not a party political matter and a decision is best reached by consensus.

As co-chair of the R&R Client Board, I should make clear that the February 2026 report, Delivering Restoration and Renewal of the Palace of Westminster: The Costed Proposals , was agreed before I joined the Board and was elected as Lord Speaker. I played no part in determining its recommendations. I acknowledge the enormous amount of work undertaken by the R&R Client Team, Delivery Authority and Strategic Estates. Their officials and experts have worked diligently within the remit and instructions given to them by Parliament.

There is no doubt that the Palace needs substantial restoration. Its ageing services and historic fabric require attention, and the safety of those who work in and visit Parliament must remain paramount. However, the passage of time, the experience gained since the programme was established and the considerable work undertaken to date inevitably raise questions about whether the balance previously struck remains appropriate .

Decisions about the scope of the works , the budget, the timescale and the governance arrangements were made in good faith, in the circumstances prevailing at the time. But things have changed, costs and practical difficulties have become clearer, and Parliament now has considerably more information on which to base its decisions. It is now reasonable if not essential to reconsider whether the balance between scope, affordability, disruption and effective governance remains right.

This reassessment is particularly important in the light of the enormous pressures on the public finances. The demands on public expenditure are already substantial, across health, education, social care and other essential services. The difficulties are compounded by the need to devote significantly greater resources to national defence and security at a time of profound international uncertainty.

These competing demands cannot be ignored when Parliament considers committing many billions of pounds to the renewal of its own buildings. Expenditure on the Palace must be judged against the same standards of necessity, affordability and value for money that Parliament expects to apply elsewhere in the public sector.

The question is not whether the Palace should be restored, but whether the scope, cost and duration of the programme originally envisaged remains justified in today ' s circumstances .

Why spend up to £ 3 billion before deciding what to do?

The Costed Proposals report recommends authorising up to £ 3 billion of preparatory expenditure over the next seven years, reducing the options under consideration from four to two, and postponing the final decision on the restoration programme until no later than mid-2030.

Some preparatory expenditure is undoubtedly necessary. But the proposed works include preparing temporary accommodation for both Houses, purchasing the Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre from a government department, constructing a river jetty, creating office accommodation in the Victoria Tower and digging a service tunnel under the Palace itself.

It is particularly important to recognise that almost all of the proposed £ 3 billion of initial expenditure would not be spent on restoring the external fabric and essential services in the Palace itself. Much of it would instead be devoted to preparatory works , temporary accommodation, decant arrangements and infrastructure required to facilitate a future restoration programme.

Although these works could support either option , much of the expenditure might serve little purpose if Parliament subsequently decided not to proceed with either.

Should Parliament commit such substantial sums before deciding which restoration programme it wishes to undertake? Would these commitments effectively restrict the choices available to a future Parliament?

Delay is itself costly. I wrote to the Client Board in June expressing concern about the cost of postponing the parliamentary debate, then estimated at £ 100 million and now exceeding £ 200 million. But that makes it all the more important to resolve the fundamental questions promptly.

Should the scope, budget and timescale now be reconsidered?

The two retained options envisage a comprehensive overhaul of the Palace, delivering what the report describes as a reasonably ambitious outcome.

Both address essential requirements: fire safety, building services, asbestos management and conservation of the historic fabric.

They also include improved accessibility, visitor and education facilities, upgraded accommodation, environmental measures, enhanced security and improvements to catering and logistics .

Many of these may be desirable, but has Parliament distinguished essential restoration from improvements that could be deferred or undertaken separately?

Should the scope agreed in 2023 be reconsidered in the light of current financial circumstances?

The Costed Proposals report included an estimated cost of full decant of up to £ 11.5 billion excluding inflation, or £ 15.6 billion including it. EMI+ is estimated at up to £ 18.7 billion excluding inflation, or £ 39.2 billion including it.

The report stated that the programmes could last up to 24 and 61 years respectively.

These estimates were based on an expected completion date no later than 2039 for the renovation of the Northern Estate, which is intended to provide temporary accommodation for the House of Commons during R&R works.

Substantial additional restoration and major projects work amounting to more than £5 billion and involving well over 100 projects is already being undertaken on the parliamentary estate, including the exterior of Victoria Tower, building services, fire safety and the Northern Estate.

However, I have recently been made aware that, since publication of the Costed Proposals in February, further developments have pushed the estimated completion date for the Northern Estate back to 2042, with a knock-on impact on the recommended options for R&R.

The Client Team estimates that, in the worst case, delays to the Northern Estate project could result in an £800m increase to the overall cost of the full decant option and an additional seven years to its timescale.

Buckingham Palace ' s 10 -year reservicing programme, which cost around £400m , offers lessons worth examining about phased construction, asbestos management, continued occupation and cost control.

How can costs be reduced?

An important factor in the very substantial cost estimates is the allowance contractors must make for uncertainty. Where the scope of a project is unclear, decisions are delayed or requirements are liable to change , contractors will inevitably cost more.

Parliament can help reduce these costs by establishing a clear and agreed specification of the works at the outset, supported by governance arrangements capable of making timely , authoritative decisions which, once taken, will be adhered to.

Clarity of scope and certainty of decision - making should enable contractors to price the work with greater confidence, reducing the risk premiums that Parliament would otherwise have to pay.

The objective is not to eliminate the unavoidable risks of restoring a historic building, but to avoid paying unnecessarily for risks created by uncertainty about Parliament ' s own requirements and decision-making.

How long should Parliament be prepared to leave the Palace?

The two recommended options envisage the House of Lords leaving its c hamber for up to 15 years under full decant and up to 13 years under EMI+. The House of Lords has never voted on whether it would agree to such prolonged displacement and both proposals are based on the assumption that it will do so.

Under EMI+, there is the further question of the Commons occupying the Lords c hamber for up to two years. That would require the agreement of your Lordships.

Should we be prepared to reconsider the p arliamentary calendar? Could more extensive use be made of recesses for major works? Is a September sitting essential if a different arrangement would enable significant restoration work to be completed more quickly, efficiently and at less cost ?

Is it responsible to regard the p arliamentary timetable as entirely inflexible when considering a programme of this magnitude ?

Are the costs of more than £400 million converting the QEII Conference Centre as accommodation for the Lords justified and are the arrangements practical? How would State Openings of Parliament and other important ceremonies be conducted?

Are the governance and legislative arrangements fit for purpose?

The programme currently involves the Client Board, Programme Board, Client Team, Delivery Authority and Parliament ' s Strategic Estates teams, alongside the two Commissions , A ccounting Officers and A dministrations of both Houses.

The Client Board has approximately 25 members and the Programme Board a further 15. Does this structure provide sufficiently clear leadership and accountability for a project of such complexity?

H alf a billion pounds has already been spent on paying for design, consultancy and the Delivery Authority , which is currently costing more than a million pounds a week. In a few months' time , in the absence of a decision , it will have nothing to do.

As a result of its extensive and expensive work , the technical and financial information needed to enable Parliament to make a decisio n now is in place. There is no need to wait until 2030 to do so.

The Delivery Authority was established under the framework created by the Parliamentary Buildings (Restoration and Renewal) Act 2019. That Act was enacted in good faith to facilitate the restoration of the Palace. Legislation should serve the needs of Parliament and the public, not become an obstacle to a more practical, affordable or effective approach.

If experience has demonstrated that the statutory framework now constrains our ability to undertake essential works in a timely and cost-effective manner, should we consider amending or, if necessary, repealing the Act ?

The fact that Parliament legislated for a particular approach in 2019 is not , in itself, a reason to retain it in 2026. If changing the legislation would benefit Parliament, improve delivery and secure better value for the public purse, should that option not deserve serious consideration ?

Decision t ime

It would be wrong to suggest that essential work should be delayed. The cost and risks of inaction are considerable. But there is an important distinction between proceeding with necessary safety and conservation work and committing billions of pounds to a programme whose scope, affordability and consequences have yet to be agreed.

The question before Parliament is not whether earlier decisions were justified when they were taken, but whether they remain the right decisions today.

At a time when the country faces exceptionally difficult choices over public expenditure , Parliament must be able to demonstrate that it has subjected expenditure on its own buildings to the most rigorous scrutiny. I urge colleagues to read the Costed Proposals report and consider these issues carefully before the debate.

The Palace of Westminster is a national treasure which we have a duty to preserve. We also have a duty to ensure that the means chosen are necessary, affordable and properly accountable.

I am copying this letter to Mr Speaker, the Leader of the House of Commons, The Rt Hon Sir Alan Campbell MP, all members of the R&R Client Board and the Prime Minister.

Disclaimer: Curated by HT Syndication.